Home » Italy news » Currently Reading:

Rom or Romanian?

November 10, 2007 Italy news 10 Comments

As I wrote a few days back, Italy has taken measures to extradite European Union citizens who have been involved in criminal activities here. The Italian law enforcement spotlight has been shining heavily on those from Romania, and the police have been rounding up Romanians by the dozen in preparation for having them sent back to Romania.

I’ve noticed that the press here has been becoming a little confused, and it is evident that they are not really sure of the difference between Romanians and the ‘Rom’. Just to make matters more confusing, which indeed they are it has to be said, both Rom and Romanians come from Romania! Indeed, one may think that ‘Rom’ is a diminutive form of ‘Romanian’, but this is not the case.

Just in case someone was wondering, the ‘Rom’, who hail from Romania, are really a nomadic gypsy type population, whereas ‘Romanians’ are those from Romania, who, in the main, are not nomadic gypsies. In fact, the ‘real’ Romanians regard their ‘Rom’ counterparts as being something of an unwanted underclass, and Romanians do not really like to be associated with the ‘Rom’. I told you it was confusing.

It becomes worse. Both true, shall we say, Romanian illegal immigrants, and the Rom live in favella type encampments, found, as far as I believe, throughout Italy, but I’m not sure that both Rom and Romanians can be found living side by side in the same shanty towns. Whilst the Romanians are quite recent immigrants, many of the Rom have been in Italy for a long time.

Around Milan, the Rom, not the Romanians, are well organised and raise funds through busking, cleaning car windows, and begging. They, the Rom, are not averse to a little fund raising petty crime either, as anyone who has seen the groups of unkempt kids carrying newspapers and surrounding tourists in an attempt to remove wallets, cash and cameras, will know. I have seen these people in action, and while she was with our son, even my other half was approached, (nothing happened, Cristina is very streetwise) – but this incident illustrates that these little gangs don’t solely prey on tourists. Most travel guides contain warnings about these nasty little gangs. Well, these gangs are part of the Rom network.

‘True’, Romanians have become involved in petty, and more serious crime, but not as a result of falling in with the Rom, at least I do not believe so. In general Romanians come to Italy in search of a better life, whereas the Rom just come here to live and operate as they always have done, in other words, as gypsies. As you may appreciate, distinguishing between these two groups that have the same places of origin can be a little mind boggling at times. Hence the confusion in the some of the Italian press.

The enforcers of law and order on the other hand, are not attempting to differentiate between Rom and Romanians, and are doing their level best to use the recent government initiative to round up and send home both Rom and Romanians. Both are now personae non gratae as far as the Italian authorities are concerned.

With regard to Italians in general, I think it would be true to say that both Rom and Romanians will not be missed particularly. Although this whole thing must be making the lives of the honest established Romanians quite difficult.

We shall see how long this extradition initiative endures, but, as is often the case here, the enthusiasm, if you can call it that, of the authorities will probably wane in a few months time, and it is probable that both Rom and Romanians will creep back into Italy. Back to square one.

Currently there are "10 comments" on this Article:

  1. Zied says:

    I heard about the Rom issue in one of the Radio Due podcasts. As you said, the Italian media itself is confused. The radio host was interviewing a Romanian maid about the differences between Rom(s) and Romanians- Now I haven’t been to Italy but I know a gypsy when I see one- The Romanian maid expressed her prejudice toward the Rom and how they are not considered as Romanians back home. According to her, soon after the communist regime fell, the Roms have been the cause of turbulence in Romania. It’s just a shame that the entire Romanian community is feeling the heat.

    Thanks for the post

  2. Zied says:

    I should also point out to your readers that the Romanies are originally from India and moved to Europe in the Middle Ages and may be differentiated from The ‘true’ Romanians-as you put it- by their darker features.

  3. admin says:

    Zied,

    Thanks for your comments on this confusing issue – I assume that you are Romanian.

    I should highlight that to make matters a little worse, the correct term for ‘Rom’ is, apparently (BBC website) ‘Roma’ in English, a word which is even closer to ‘Romanian’.

    But one thing I did not point out in my post above, and that my other half mentioned to me, is that not all ‘Roma’ are from Romania, which makes associating ‘Roma’ with Romanians even less accurate.

    Alas though, many, including the press in Italy, do not really know this, but non-Roma Romanians are still being confused with Roma, whether or not they come from Romania, and all Romanians are ending up with a bad reputation as a result.

    Yes, the whole situation is horribly confusing, and non-Rom/Roma Romanians are suffering the most as a result.

    Kind regards,

    Alex

  4. Zied says:

    Alex,

    Actually I’m not even European. I reside in the States. I’ve always considered these groups “Gypsies” or “Zingari” maybe that’s what your partner means. The “Rom” term is new to me, and had to google it after I had heard the abovementioned interview on RadioRai- Which led me to your interesting blog that I’ll be revisiting soon to see what else I can learn from you.

    Thanks,

  5. admin says:

    Hi Zied,

    Thanks for your reply. So, you are from the States. How come this Rom thing interests you?

    Before living in Italy, I had not heard of the Rom thing either, but I did know about gypsies, although where I come from, the UK, gypsies do not appear to come from the Rom population. However, in Italy most of the so-called gypsies are Rom, although I am prepared to be corrected on this, as it is really only my impression. I’m not sure whether the Rom gypsies are to be found in other European countries.

    Glad to hear that you find my blog interesting. If you do manage learn something, let me know. In fact, let me know if you don’t, too!

    Thanks for dropping in.

    All the best,

    Alex (also known as ‘admin’, by the way)

  6. Cristina says:

    good job in distinguishing between Rom (gypsies) and Romanians. As a Romanian, I really appreciate that people stop to think abt these problems and not just put a ‘stamp’ and let the situation be. True, I’m having second thoughts abt traveling to Italy for a while though [what Romanian wouldn't?]

  7. Claudia says:

    Thank you for making the difference between Romanians and Gypsies clearr. They should not be called “roma”, but gypsies.

    Also, you should also write about the 1,000,000 Romanians working in construction. 1% of italy’s GNP comes from them, and indeed, everything built in Italy in the last 10-15 years was done with Romanian sweat.

  8. Laura says:

    What’s up with Italians wanting to extradite Romanians… which are the same people? It’s gypsies (Roma) who are the cause of most troubles (in BOTH countries actually) and who are INDIAN!!! They are not european!! I guess Italians are turning on their own people now……
    So all this anti-romanian crap that is going around is ridiculous! Gypsies aren’t even romanian, they live all throughout europe and a lot of them happend to live in Romania but they’re clearly NOT white!

  9. fly says:

    Rom=gipsy;romanian are the people of Romania,the white people and not the dark skin whitch are gypsy;is very easy to understand..they are an etnic group from Romania..there are a lot of etnic groups in Romania(Hungarians,germans etc)but the most different one(because not from europe bue indians)are the gipsy;so people..please.,.when you see a drak skin person who’s saying that come from Roamania..that’s means that the person is gipsy!grazie…Romanians=Dacians…….Gypsy=indians=nomads

  10. Stefan says:

    Let’s look at history a bit.

    The true ancestors of the Romanian people were the Dacians (as Fly said) – Decebal, Burebista, Zalmoxe are a few notable names. The Dacians were a mixture between Tracs and Gets (indo-europeans that migrated to central and eastern-europe).

    Now, the Dacians and the Romans (the people of the Roman empire) – Traian is a notable name – formed the Romanian people we know today (the process started somewhere in the first century before Christ if i remember from history class correctly).

    The nomadic Roma people (gypsy, gitan, tigan, rom) came to this country a lot later. But not all gypsy people are Romanian, This is a problem that keeps coming up. When people find out you’re Romanian they say.. “ah.. so you’re a gypsy”.

    There are gypsy people in Span, France, Italy, Bulgaria, Romania, Hungary and in most countries of eastern Europe. Romania is not the land of the gypsies. Italy have their own, Bulgaria have their own, even Spain have their own gypsies.

    The one thing i hate about all this extradation of gypsies from France and Italy is this: before Romania was accepted in the EU, we were called racist and intolerant and we were asked to create special social-integration programs for the gypsies in our country. So we did. Then, after Romania entered the EU and the border gates flew open, many gypsies went to western european countries to steal and beg (things they did, and still do, here in Romania). What’s happening now? The french government is paying 350 euros per gypsy to send them back to Romania. For a lack of a better word i’d say this is bribery!

    And what do the gypsies do? They come to Romania with a smile on their face and say “well the french government paid us to come on vacation in our country. we are going back to France next week”

    So who is racist and intolerant now?

    Don’t get me wrong. NOT all gypsies are robbers and beggars! I guarantee that. But the truth is that most of them do these things and Romania is blamed for it like it’s some sort of motherland to the gypsies. IT’S NOT!

    I’ve made my point.
    Thanks for reading it.

    Stefan
    Bucharest, Romania

Comment on this Article:







Recent Comments

  • nikki herrington: Could you share your friends information with me? I am comin...
  • Al: Hi Sam,You gave Alex’s page on “Speeding, and other traf...
  • Sam: Hi AlThanks Al and Alex for the very useful information ...
  • PabloUK: Irm,As you will have seen from earlier posts in this thr...
  • Digital Food Photography in Siena: Ciao Melania: Both Alessandro and Barbara are professionals...

Advert

Book Luxury Italy Holidays - CItalia the leading Italian specialist

Globalpost

Blog From Italy at Blogged

Essential Italy Books from Amazon.co.uk

Useful Links

Hire a car in Italy
Auto-Europe - Car Hire Italy
Buy Italian Wine
Oliver McCrum Wines
Go Tuscany!
Tuscany Villas

The 442 Pub in Milan

442 Pub Milan

Blog Flux Directory

Find the best blogs at Blogs.com.

Visit Beautiful Italy

Want to visit beautiful Italy? Start your trip in Rome and book one of the hotels in Rome through EasyToBook.com. EasyToBook.com are a Blog from Italy contributor.

Hotels in Rome

Want to visit Rome? Take a look through Expedia.co.uk's selection of hotels in Rome. Expedia.co.uk are a Blog from Italy contributor.

Follow Blog from Italy

Via RSS: Blog from Italy's Feed

To get Italy flavour news and updates via Twitter, follow: @newsfromitaly 2300+ followers and counting.

Italy News

Francesco Cossiga Understood Italy

18 Aug 2010

For those who did not know, Francesco Cossiga, who died the other day, was an Italian politician and one time President of Italy. Cossiga hailed from Sardinia, was a fan of John Le Carre and had earned himself the nickname “the pickaxe” owing to his no holds barred criticism of other Italian politicians.

Berlusconi v Fini – Slinging Old Mud

12 Aug 2010

As you may be aware, the generally tumultus world of Italian politics is in turmoil. The Berlusconi government is teetering on the brink of collapse, but what is really surprising, is that this collapse was sparked from the inside.

Berlusconi Divorces Fini

30 Jul 2010

Kotipizza Berlusconi

From spat to full-blown split. Silvio Berlusconi’s marriage of political convenience to Gianfranco Fini has ended in tears. Scorned lover Berlusconi even rejected Fini’s last minute attempts to kiss and make up and remain part of Berlusconi’s party of love. End of love in. Period.

Ads

Related Posts

At Sixes and Sevens – Confusion Reigns

Did the expression ‘at sixes and sevens’ originate from English speakers who had dealings with Italians? There does seem to be some evidence.

Italy – The Vatican and the Mafia

When mention is made of Italy mixed in with thoughts of pasta and wine will be the Vatican and, the mafia.

A list of Ways Italy Could Save Money

Those who know a little about Italy’s wobbly economy will know that public spending levels are reaching record highs.
So, how could Italy save a few bucks? Read on for a list of ten ideas.

The Italian Newsstand

This week’s images of Italy photo shows a newsstand in Umbria, Italy, which has a charming little extra ‘guarding’ all those valuable publications. It’s a lovely capture.

Anglitaliano – English Invades Italian

A guest post from someone who has noticed odd things happening to the ‘Italian’ language. Over to you Ainsley:

As a Northern 40-something-year-old Englishman, the four years I’ve spent learning Italian haven’t exactly been plain sailing (blame the British school system).